Proposal to Partner With and Whitelist Candle (CNDL)

BancorDAO Partnership and Whitelist Proposal for Candle

This proposal is expected to appear on Snapshot for voting on Saturday, March 19th, 2022 at 12:00 pm UTC

Summarize Here

  • Proposal to whitelist Candle (CNDL).
  • Proposed trading liquidity limit is 20,000 BNT.
  • There are no apparent security concerns that would prohibit whitelist status we think.
  • We believe in the legitimacy of Candle and in their long term success.
  • We think the benefit for Bancor is clear.

CNDL token address: 0xbc138bD20C98186CC0342C8e380953aF0cb48BA8

Project Website: https://candlelabs.org

Token Security

Candle (CNDL) does not have an elastic supply, or rebase mechanism. The CNDL contracts do not have permissions that grant administrators unrestricted mint/burn capabilities. The CNDL token supply is fixed at 100,000,000,000 of which 416,009,556 are in current circulation. The contracts and addresses with the highest concentration of CNDL tokens are predominantly the governance contracts, one of the Exchange wallets, two of the team’s wallets, and an AAVE V2 lending pool. The team wallets and vesting contracts are discussed here.

Project

The Candle project provides technology for building dApp’s, products, services, and more within an interoperable and connected ecosystem, based on the Candle Platform. Candle is a distributed network of app’s and products offered by anyone who builds and integrates into their platform, rather than a single trusted entity. As with any distributed system, Candle is nearly impossible to compromise, as the adversary must control the majority of the network to influence its behaviour. Therefore, Candle offers a compelling solution to bridging the gap between convenience, unification, and the need for Decentralization. Due to the general nature of products and services, and the already well-established and rapidly growing use of smart contracts, Candle serves a clear purpose now and in the future. Candle has set it’s own team of developers to build the first suite of app’s and services within this ecosystem, focused on religion and spirituality - morality. You can read more about that on their website here.

Tokenomics

Cande’s native token, CNDL (ERC20), is required to access, and participate in the network. Candle must be accepted as a currency by any app or service that integrates into its ecosystem. Candle is also the governance currency of the network; users must hold Candle to participate and vote on the future of the platform and associated ecosystem. Therefore, the Candle token is a utility token, and not merely a symbolic representation of the project.

Community and Communication

Candle is active on Telegram and Discord. The Candle team also operates official an Twitter account. Activity on GitHub is frequent, with new updates appearing every two to eight days. The development team and advisors are presented on the team tab on the Candle website. Patrick Prince, the co-founder and CEO of Candle, is the project’s main spokesperson. The CNDL website includes a mailing address in Dover, Delaware, USA, and four contact emails:

Market and Trading Data

  • CNDL’s price at the time of writing is $0.028
  • All-time high: $0.12 (22nd of January 2022)
  • All-time low: $0.00012 (29th December, 2021)
  • 416,009,556 tokens in circulation
  • 100,000,000,000 maximum supply.
  • The current market capitalization is $11,648,267.56

Benefits for Bancor:

  • Brings new traders into the Bancor Ecosystem
  • Extensive marketing of the pool, as it will be the deepest pool for Candle
  • Two year commitment to maintain, publicize, and support the health of the pool
  • The entire Candle community will use Bancor and this pool within the time period, exclusively
  • High incentives offered by the Candle Governors to support the integration of our two communities

Voter Incentives

  • Each voter is eligible for an immediate gift of 2,000 Candle (CNDL). From MBR, Snapshot generates a CSV file of all voting members who participated in each proposal. Simply vote on Snapshot and your information will be added to the relevant CSV file! That’s it. An alternative is to email [email protected] with the same information.
  • All voters will be offered exclusive access to the Candle Governors community chat.
  • All voters will be given, should they accept, a Candle Bancor NFT to commemorate this partnership. Bancor’s Snapshot uses Proof Of Attendance Protocol (POAP) to mint NFTs for active voters, and the minting period will be the day after voting ends. It’ll be open for 48 hours, and all eligible voters will be able to able to mint this NFT. Eligible voters are based on the previously mentioned Snapshot CSV file.
  • All voters will be granted exclusive access to titles and priority access to the Candle beta.

Thank you so much for taking the initiative!

I think that we might have a slightly less cumbersome solution to the voting proof - I think these systems ought to make for a much more robust proof of voting participation.

I also note that the commemorative NFT (nice idea!) is only mintable during the voting period - this might be more difficult to enforce, although it can still be done. If you like, we could move the NFT minting period to the day after the voting ends (i.e. hold it open only for 24 hours, or whatever you think is appropriate), which would allow for the list of eligible voters to be generated via the tools available on Snapshot.

I moved this proposal back to Level 1.
The only way for a proposal to appear on Level 2 is for it to be promoted from Level 1.

Thank you so much for taking the initiative!

I think that we might have a slightly less cumbersome solution to the voting proof - Snapshot generates a csv file of all voting members who participated in each proposal, and we also use Proof Of Attendance Protocol (POAP) to mint NFTs for active voters. I think these systems ought to make for a much more robust proof of voting participation.

I also note that the commemorative NFT (nice idea!) is only mintable during the voting period - this might be more difficult to enforce, although it can still be done. If you like, we could move the NFT minting period to the day after the voting ends (i.e. hold it open only for 24 hours, or whatever you think is appropriate), which would allow for the list of eligible voters to be generated via the tools available on Snapshot.

1 Like

I agree, that does sound much easier and simpler! I’ll update the post now, thank you!

1 Like

So, I have some concerns about this proposal, and about the CNDL token that I would like to share.

The project website does not fill me with confidence. The title image is an L-shaped prism with an apparently unfinished, or at least poorly-cropped candle logo appended to it.

I don’t mean to suggest that we judge the merits of a project on the strength of their graphic design, but this is substantially under par. It could be that graphic design simply isn’t your forte - and that’s fine. However, there doesn’t seem to be a product of any kind, either in development or currently available. The “app” button simply leads to the Dodo swap page:

The blog page is a subreddit with only 4 posts in it, two of which are links to the CoinGecko and CoinMarketCap pages. None of the four posts have any activity of any kind (zero comments).

Despite these apparent shortcomings, the FDV of the project is close to $3,000,000,000, and its DAO treasury has 60% of that.

The recent vote on the Candle project’s Snapshot, which was apparently to come to a decision about deploying a pool on Bancor, lasted only 1 hour, and ended with zero votes. Some of the other proposals in this DAO Snapshot are just bizarre. The proposed upgrade to multichain voting saw a single core wallet vote with 99,000,000,000 CNDL, and the decision ended with a 4,950,000% quorum. The only other proposals to date are regarding the dimensions of the icon, expand burning to polygon(?), focus on metaverse, and my personal favorite, Join Coinbase.

The brevity of this last proposal is breathtaking.

image

In the project’s documentation, under the heading “For Engineers”, the following text can be found:

(1) Candle token is built on Ethereum, a scalable network for such applications and tokens. It is used in conjunction with the (2) web app to allow users to burn their tokens by pressing on the (3) Burn button and typing their message into the message box. The (4) Candle Smart Contract is deployed on Ethereum, and is the formation and logic behind the Candle token. The (5) Candle Burn smart contract is our custom built solution for allowing the functionality of the Burn button and message box mentioned earlier. After a burn and accompanying message are on the blockchain, the (6) Candle Burn Explorer fetches all instances of this and displays it and other useful information on a webpage, allowing users and others to visualize and see data and history. (7) Candle CVI is the Candle Confession Volatility Index, which is tracked against the use of the burn function and messages that are categorized as confessions.

If you are legitimately trying to establish a religionDAO, or confessionDAO, or something to that end, I sincerely wish you well. Unfortunately there are just way too many problems with the CNDL token at present, and while I can’t speak for anyone except myself, I can’t see anyone with the required vBNT stake wishing to support your proposal on your behalf by pushing it to Snapshot for you.

Of course, your proposal will remain on Level 1 with sufficient time to engage with members of our community. If someone is willing to support your proposal, then I will be happy to hear from them. Until then, please reach out to me directly as there is a security questionnaire regarding the CNDL token that should be completed prior to the proposal’s promotion to Level 2 (if indeed it gets that far).

Good luck with your project! Please don’t feel that the token’s unsuitability for the Bancor whitelist necessarily reflects badly on your efforts. I can see that most of the work has been done only in the last few days - give it some time, and please feel free to return when there is a little more momentum inside your community.

2 Likes

Must voice my concearn here and give a resounding No. I urge community members to look at my thoughts below.

These Wallets Make up basically the entirety of the Market Cap and with so little of the token supply in circulation that puts the Fully Diluted Valuation at 3 Billion USD. Furthermore there is absolutely no liquidity on this token whatsoever, the primary means of swapping linked on the site cannot even handle a 15$ Trade.

Voting for this would be essentially gifting 5 Million Dollars to a team we know nothing about. Even if they are not malicious we would only serve as exit liquidity for their Expenses.

Vote NO

4 Likes

Yeah, This is a hard no from me.

2 Likes

Looking even further into it this is absolutely going to be the case as is clearly outlined in their Docs:

At current prices thats $450 Million USD that can be instantly dumped on us to pay for an advertising campaign.

@mbr You front ran my post by 5 minutes while I was putting it together lmao just noticed.

4 Likes

Hi. The snapshot proposals are tests. We are early indeed. Thanks.